Rule number 1.
Never give up on them. At the end of the day, its just a bunch of monkeys in an office trying to keep their nose clean. Comet do not like bad things said about them, as at the end of the day, they arent so bad. However, regarding the rules when it comes to faults with products, they bend them and break them.
The Soga helps customers recover damages for up to 6 years in England, 5 years in Scotland regardless of the product. This is your most invaluable tool, however also posting about it on the internet is also. It does not mean that faulty products need to be repaired or replaced free of charge however. Please remember that, any food lost in a freezed can be claimed back, regardless of what they say. As long as you provide sufficient evidence that the malfunction caused the food to be lost within a freezer compartment, legally they would have to pay out so would recommend pursing this continually until you get a result.
Regarding a repair, Comet would not have to repair it free of charge as they offer a sliding scale based repair policy to assist customers. Any product faulty within 18 months must be repaired free of charge, this includes laptops and cameras/camcorders. You may however need to pay a fee to get the item inspected, as more often than not its the manufacturer who has to inspect the product, if found to be faulty with a major component failure, recover the costs from the retailer. You can also demand for a free of charge inspection on anything repaired by Comets own engineers.
Anything outside of 18 months, you will be charged an inspection fee and for any major components at fault, can look to obtain a sizeable discount on the cost of repairing it. If it cannot be repaired, they have to either offer you a market monetary value replacement (EG 42 inch flat screen goes wrong 6 years down the line in the uk, is irrepairable, they have to and will end up replacing for a TV worth 1 6th of its original value. They will however challenge this, and state as its lasted so long without fault, its not unreasonable to suggest the goods had no inherent faults when manufactured. There is no proof of this, and why else would a product fail. If its fit for purpose, you should be able to have it on for 6 years without fault, as this is what the Soga was put in place for.
Right, without going any further on a tangent - regarding your problem, take it to them. Hit em up. This is 24 months old, and is faulty. If they continually refuse assistance when this is a 100% definite fault, especially if a major component, they HAVE to help. IF they do not, write to their directors team. Simples.
Regards,
Hitemup